Stephen Dunn

What They Wanted

They wanted me to tell the truth,

so I said I’d lived among them

for years, a spy,

but all that I wanted was love.

They said they couldn’t love a spy.

Couldn’t I tell them other truths?

I said I was emotionally bankrupt,

would turn any of them in for a kiss.

I told them how a kiss feels

when it’s especially undeserved;

I thought they’d understand.

They wanted me to say I was sorry,

so I told them I was sorry.

They didn’t like it that I laughed.

They asked what I’d seen them do,

and what I do with what I know.

I told them: find out who you are

before you die.

Tell us, they insisted, what you saw.

I saw the hawk kill a smaller bird.

I said life is one long leavetaking.

They wanted me to speak 

like a journalist.  I’ll try, I said.

I told them I could depict the end

of the world, and my hand wouldn’t tremble.

I said nothing’s serious except destruction.

They wanted to help me then.

They wanted me to share with them,

that was the word they used, share.

I said it’s bad taste

to want to agree with many people.

I told them I’ve tried to give

as often as I’ve betrayed.

They wanted to know my superiors,

to whom did I report?

I told them I accounted to no one,

that each of us is his own punishment.

If I love you, one of them cried out,

what would you give up?

There were others before you,

I wanted to say, and you’d be the one

before someone else.  Everything, I said.

 

Stephen Dunn

 Stephen  DunnStephen Dunn is the author of fourteen collections of poetry, including the recent Everything Else in the World (Norton), which was awarded the Paterson Prize for Sustained Literary Acheivement.  His Different Hours won the 2001 Pulitzer Prize.  A book of his essays and memoirs, Walking Light, is available from BOA.  He divides his time between Frostburg, Maryland and southern New Jersey, where he is Distinguished Professor of Creative Writing at Richard Stockton College.
More info